Head-to-head comparison guides
Choosing an analytics tool should not mean trusting a sales page.
Side-by-side tables of quietstats against Cloudflare Web Analytics, Simple Analytics, Umami and Matomo, with every fact taken from the provider’s own live page on 19 November 2026.
Why quietstats: you get this without cookies, a consent banner or storing IP addresses, in every plan including Free.
In every plan, including Free. Privacy and performance.
📘 Step-by-step guide, with screenshots and diagrams →
Start free, no cardSee live demo
- No cookies or consent banner
- No IP addresses stored
- Groups under 5 visitors hidden
- 845-byte script
- Free plan, no card


What it is
Four more head-to-head pages join the Plausible, Fathom and Google Analytics ones: a new page for Cloudflare Web Analytics, and side-by-side tables added to the existing Simple Analytics, Umami and Matomo pages. Each row shows our answer and theirs (price, free plan, sites, cookies, where data is processed, open source, UTM tags, events, sampling and script size), links the page we read and gives the date. Script sizes were measured the same day.
Why it matters
Choosing an analytics tool should not mean trusting a sales page. Dated, sourced facts let you check every claim yourself, including where another tool is the better choice.
How it works
- Open /compare and pick a tool under “More head to heads”.
- Read each row; follow “Source” to the provider’s own page.
- Read “Where the other tool may fit better” before deciding.
Privacy: what is and isn’t collected
Collected
- Nothing: public pages
Never collected
- Anything about who reads them
- Cookies, localStorage or anything else stored on the visitor’s device
- IP addresses or user agents (used in memory, then discarded)
- Anything that links a visitor across days (the visitor ID resets daily)
Rows and limits
- Prices and plans change; every row says when it was checked
- Script sizes are one day’s measurement
- We only state what the provider’s pages say; where they say nothing, we say so
“Rows” are database rows written, which is what our hosting is billed on. Reads are not rows written. Methodology →
Questions
How do you keep the facts honest?
Every competitor fact quotes the provider’s own page. A script re-fetches each page and checks the quoted words are still there; all quotes matched on 19 November 2026.
Do you say when another tool is better?
Yes. Each page has a section on where the other tool may fit better.
Related features
Privacy and performanceUnder 1 KB script and single-page apps
Privacy and performanceMetrics handbook
See your trafficFree tools: script size calculator and cookie banner checker
Privacy and performanceMethodology for every deep-dive report
Privacy and performanceSpeed vs engagement: do slow pages lose visitors?
Privacy and performanceSingle-page app add-on: #/ routes, back/forward restores and prerendering
Privacy and performanceHigh contrast and larger text: easier to read, everywhere in the app
Privacy and performance
All privacy and performance features → · All features → · Docs: Head-to-head comparison guides guide → · Compare features with other tools →
Guides on this topic
Set it up
Nothing to set up: it works with the standard one-line script.
<script data-host="https://quietstats.co.uk" data-dnt="true" src="https://quietstats.co.uk/js/script.js" id="YOUR_SITE_ID" async defer></script>Try it on your own site
Free during launch: one site and 5,000 pageviews a month, no card needed. After launch, paid plans start at £5 a month.